Whether a concierge membership is worth the annual fee has less to do with the fee than with how you use primary care and what has been missing from it. A healthy 30-year-old who sees a doctor once every few years and a 55-year-old juggling blood pressure, cholesterol, and three specialists will reach different answers, and both can be right.
Rather than a sales pitch, this is a set of questions to work through honestly. If most of your answers point the same way, you will have your decision. For a closer look at what the fee itself covers, see our earlier post on concierge medicine costs in Chicago.
Question One: How Often Do You Actually Need Your Doctor?
Start with your last two years. Count the sick visits, follow-ups for ongoing conditions, prescription questions, referrals, and the times you needed an answer quickly and could not get one.
Traditional practice physicians often see 15 to 20 patients a day in 15-minute appointments and can carry panels of more than two thousand patients. Patients can wait weeks to be seen. If that describes your experience and you need care more than once or twice a year, the access a membership provides, including sick visits generally the same or next day, is where much of the value sits.
It also helps to think about what a quick answer would have saved you: a missed afternoon of work, an urgent care trip that turned out to be unnecessary, or a worry that lingered for a week. Those costs rarely show up on a bill, but they are part of the comparison.
If you rarely need care beyond an annual visit, the case is weaker on access alone, and it comes down to the remaining questions.
Question Two: Are You Managing Something Ongoing?
Chronic conditions reward continuity. When the same physician follows your numbers over years, small changes stand out, and adjustments happen sooner. Dr. Cahill's membership includes routine follow-up visits for chronic disease management, along with an annual wellness visit and annual screening blood tests (CBC, CMP, A1c, lipids, and thyroid), plus an annual screening EKG when appropriate.
For patients managing high blood pressure, diabetes risk, weight, or several conditions at once, this kind of steady, unhurried follow-up is often the deciding factor.
Question Three: How Much Is Direct Access Worth to You?
Members can reach the practice directly by text or phone, schedule virtual appointments, and get help coordinating specialist care. That matters most for people whose time is tight or whose care involves several doctors.
Think about the last time you needed to ask a quick question about a medication, a test result or a new symptom. If the answer involved a portal message, a callback days later, and then an appointment anyway, direct access may be worth more to you than it looks on paper.
Question Four: Can You Carry Both a Membership and Insurance?
This is the question people skip, and it is the one that matters most financially. A concierge membership does not replace health insurance. Sean Cahill, MD, does not accept insurance payments for the practice's medical services, which are covered by the annual fee, but you still need insurance for:
Lab work that is not part of the annual visit
Vaccines given in the office
Screening or diagnostic testing done outside the office
Specialist visits, emergency room care, and hospital stays
Some patients use their health savings accounts to pay the annual fee, and the practice offers a range of discounts. Ask the office whether you qualify. If keeping both the membership and your insurance would strain your budget, that is a legitimate reason to wait.
Question Five: Do You Want Prevention or Just Problem-Solving?
Some people want a doctor for when something goes wrong. Others want someone looking ahead: tracking risk factors, planning for midlife health and building a strategy to stay well. Dr. Cahill's practice leans toward the second, with a focus on prevention, wellness, and longevity.
Prevention takes time that a short visit rarely allows: reviewing trends in your labs, talking through sleep, stress and weight, and adjusting the plan as your life changes. If you are drawn to that kind of planning, a membership gives it the time it needs. If not, a traditional practice may serve you well.
Reading Your Answers
Concierge medicine tends to be a strong fit when several of these are true:
You need care more than once or twice a year, or you have been frustrated by wait times
You are managing one or more ongoing conditions
You value reaching your physician directly
You can comfortably maintain your insurance alongside the membership
You want a long-term prevention plan, not only sick care
None of these answers is permanent. Needs change as careers, families, and health change, and a model that did not fit five years ago may fit now.
It may be worth waiting if you are healthy, rarely need care, and would have to stretch to cover both the fee and your insurance. Comparing models helps too. Our breakdown of concierge medicine and direct primary care explains how the two approaches differ.
One Physician for the Whole Household
For families, the math can shift. Dr. Cahill is board-certified in both internal medicine and pediatrics and cares for adults and children, so parents and kids can see the same physician. He completed a combined internal medicine and pediatrics residency at Loyola University, has more than 20 years of experience in the Chicago area, serves patients at Northwestern Memorial Hospital and teaches medical students and residents at Northwestern's Feinberg School of Medicine. You can read more on his physician profile.
Membership Questions We Hear Often
What does the membership cost?
Pricing is shared directly by the office. Call the practice for current membership pricing and to ask about available discounts.
What happens in an emergency?
Members receive emergency care at any facility covered by their insurance, and the practice's doctors are available to consult by phone with emergency physicians. Emergency room care is billed to your insurance.
Who covers for Dr. Cahill on weekends or vacations?
Weekend and vacation on-call coverage may be provided by one of the practice's affiliated physicians.
Will it be hard to get an appointment?
Membership is built around a limited number of patients so that appointments are easy to schedule. Sick visits are generally available the same or next day, and visits are longer than a typical primary care appointment.
Can I use my HSA for the annual fee?
Some patients use their health savings accounts to pay the annual fee. Check with your HSA administrator or tax advisor about your own situation.
How do I start?
Contact the office to discuss membership details and schedule a Meet & Greet appointment, an opportunity to ask your questions before you commit.
Bring Your Answers to a Meet & Greet
If you have worked through these questions and want to compare notes with Dr. Cahill, send the office a message to set up a Meet & Greet. Bring your list of current medications and the questions that matter most to you, and use the visit to decide whether the membership fits your life.